Why Do I Replay Conversations in My Head? The Hidden Cycle of Social Anxiety

As you walk away from a social gathering with potential new friends, you can’t stop judging yourself for how you spoke and acted. You didn’t talk much and you don’t recall saying anything interesting. You’re left with the uncomfortable conclusion that you blew an opportunity to make new friends and you’re certain that they think of you as boring or weird. The mental torture continues later that evening as you repeatedly replay the conversation in your head, exhausting yourself with rounds of mental review, each one confirming that you messed it all up.

If this is your typical way of processing social gatherings, then you’re likely to be grappling with significant social anxiety (also called social phobia). Why does this happen? Why can’t you stop the thought loop? How come you can’t be kind to yourself in your post-mortem assessment of a date, a networking event or a social meetup?

I’ve witnessed firsthand as a psychologist how the tendency to ruminate after social events can lead to so much mental distress and subsequent avoidance. Obsessing about your post-event social performance is the mental glue that keeps the social anxiety from improving.

What is the hidden cycle of social anxiety and rumination?

To understand the way rumination promotes future social anxiety, let’s go over a brief explanation of the cycle of social anxiety.

First, a social interaction occurs. Your mind then searches for mistakes. Negative ideas about yourself are repeated as you replay conversations and choices. Your anxiety increases.

You encode the memory in a biased way as a negative event, including all of the self-judgment and errors. Positive angles of the event are minimized or forgotten.

Social confidence decreases and self-judgment remains and fuels a standing pool of pre-existing negative ideas about yourself.

Anxiety spikes in anticipation of a potential social interaction, known or imagined. Avoidance tactics are reinforced as an option for handling a pending social engagement.

If thoughts of avoidance compel you to skip the event, immediate relief is experienced and it feels like danger was successfully averted. After a brief period of relief, the rumination begins…negative thoughts against the self increase. Self-judgment taints all of your thoughts about your avoidance and personal value. Regrets might further enhance mental discomfort. A sense of defeat and helplessness flood your thoughts.

If thoughts of avoidance don’t stop you from attending a social interaction, then your anxiety might spike prior to the event and obsessive thinking could make the lead up time very uncomfortable. At the event you’re in your own head and not so present. Things don’t feel natural. You question every choice you make. You hyper-attend to other people’s thoughts of you, wondering what they’re thinking. Since you’re not fully present, you might avoid or keep sharing about yourself to a minimum. You avoid vulnerability and self-expression, which limits your sense of belonging and of being seen, heard and validated.

If you do manage to fully engage in the social activity, the intense self-judgment following the event cancels out positive aspects of the experience. The ruminative cycle continues.

It doesn’t have to be this way. CBT therapy can interrupt this cycle. I sincerely enjoy the work I do with clients who are seeking relief from their social anxiety. 

But why do I replay events in my head?

The cycle of social anxiety reinforces the idea that you are not ____ enough. You fill in the blank. Smart? Interesting? Exciting? A fast thinker? Worthy? Desirable? Wealthy? Charismatic?

When you’re operating from the base hypothesis that you’re not ____ enough, then there’s very little room for you to interpret your behavior in a social situation as “enough” or “better than enough”. Think of it as a thought addiction. Without a way to push back on the idea that you’re not ____ enough, then you’re bound to confirm this painful belief.

Rumination/ self-evaluation (and avoidance) serve an evolutionary function of keeping you safe. A threat must be avoided. The problem is that your assessment of the threat is quite biased toward the negative. You’re likely to interpret positive outcomes through a very strong filter of negativity and minimization.

One way to think of rumination is that it’s your attempt at mastery over difficult thoughts, things you don’t want to, but fear you have to accept are true about you. The more you circle around painful ideas, the more you maintain the illusion of gaining control over such difficult thoughts.

Another way to understand rumination is that the cycle of social anxiety and post-event, obsessive thinking simply creates balance between the way you just interpreted your social performance/how you think others think of you and core beliefs about yourself (e.g., “I am unlovable” or “I am defective.”) These core assumptions are like files in your mind that are waiting to be filled with new data, and you’re on a hunt to fill up the files to the brim.

Why Does New York City tend make a mental habit of rumination worse?

In New York City, people are competing for resources. It’s so easy to slip into the mentality that other people have it together much more than you. (Please see my detailed post on how NYC worsens social anxiety for much more on this topic.) We all fall for outward appearances, that other people are doing better/ more ____ than us. You insert the adjective that suits your self-conscious concerns. Social media reinforces this bias exponentially.

There’s a sense in NYC as though people are on the hunt for achieving social credit. This makes socializing feel even more risky. You’re likely to be comparing yourself to some uber-idealized version of what you think of others are relative to your own value. So many social interactions can feel high stakes in New York when you leave your apartment.

What if my habit of ruminating after social interactions is worsened by my  perfectionistic tendencies?

Perfectionists may have higher standards for performance and an intolerance for small mistakes. When you’re comparing yourself to an idealized version of how you’re supposed to act or the reaction you’re meant to get from others, you have to literally thread the needle to leave a social interaction feeling like you’ve succeeded.

One problem with perfectionistic tendencies is that at school or work, these habits may have led you to be highly successful. Based on past success, your mind is at risk for generalizing to the social realm in terms of believing your performance around others should be nothing short of perfect.

I work with perfectionists (and non-perfectionists) in therapy to alter irrational belief systems around social performance while opening the mental pathway toward self-acceptance and curiosity instead of biased self-evaluation. Of course, you can never shut down ALL post-event self-evaluative thoughts, but they can be limited and new habits of thought can be learned.

There are thought-stopping techniques for reducing rumination, as well as strategies for promoting social confidence, which tend to short circuit the cycle of social anxiety, rumination and avoidance.

Breaking the Cycle of Social Anxiety

Judgment-laden, obsessive thoughts around social events hold the key to breaking the cycle of avoidance that often accompanies social anxiety. When you learn to restructure thought patterns associated with social performance and perceived judgment (occurring inward and from others), it becomes easier to take social chances. Reduced rumination makes room for thoughts of self-acceptance and a more realistic assessment of social risk. Perfectionistic ideas amplify self-judgment and therefore must be altered so you don’t hold yourself to impossible standards that doom you to conclude that you failed and aren’t good enough. You can learn to see social events as less high stakes, even with room for error on your part.

Some people do well with a stepwise exposure approach to building social confidence. Therapy offers a safe space to discuss social outcomes and avoidance. Anticipatory social anxiety, anxiety during socialization and post-event, social evaluation can all be improved when you’re working in therapy with an experienced psychotherapist.

Please feel free to reach out with any questions or to schedule an initial consulation.

I wish you all the best in your social endeavors!

Gregory Kushnick, Psy.D.

Licensed Psychologist in New York City

Tel. 917-566-7312

Chelsea/Flatiron Office

138 West 25th St.

Suite 802-B4

New York, NY 10001

FiDi/Wall St. Office

30 Broad St.

Suite 1433

New York, NY 10004